I hope that you have read the posts on Academics, Athletics and Community Service prior to reading this section. If you haven’t, please go back and read those sections as this section is the last “leg of the table” that make up who you are in the eyes of an evaluator.
What is leadership? Leadership is not standing in front of a group and telling them what to do and how to do it, and it certainly isn’t barking orders and threatening people. Leadership is your ability to pull people together for a common cause and, many times getting them to do something that they normally wouldn’t do on their own initiative.
Why is leadership grouped with Academics, Athletics, and Community Service? The primary role of the academies is to train leaders, officers that can lead men and women in defense of this country. You may have heard the saying, “You have to learn to follow before you can lead.” While true, it’s also important to realize that the formal academy leadership training will only be over a four year period. Very shortly after graduation, you will be leading men and women in situations that are potentially dangerous. Because of the relatively short time that the academy has to train you, they are looking for people that have exhibited leadership skills and can quickly refine those skills as junior officers.
There are many ways a student applying to an academy can display leadership whether it be on a sports team, in the community, through scouting, in a club activity, at a job, or just through life experiences. Many students are team captains and have experience leading their team, sometimes even acting as an assistant coach. Others organize clubs or a community service project and achieve a planned goal Some are required to step up due to a personal challenge. There is no right or wrong example of leadership but there is a proper way to describe the challenge that you faced, your leadership style, and the outcome.
Machiavelli asked, “It is better (for a leader) to be feared than loved if you cannot be both?” That was a tough question for 15th-century

kings and princes. Today in the 21st century, Machiavelli might ask. “Is it better to be respected or liked?” I don’t know the answer, but I do know that it will be important for you to be able to describe your leadership style. If you don’t know what your style is, think about a situation where you had to get a group to work together and how you directed them to achieve a shared goal. Also, think about what you learned about managing people and yourself during that example.
Let me give you two examples of leadership; both examples are based on real candidate interviews.
The first is a soccer player. The soccer player was the varsity team captain during his sophomore year. He went to a small school and all the senior players were his friends. During the middle of the season, the coach had a heart attack. The coach had directed every aspect of the team from each play of practice to when the players could take a water break; the coach was king. After the coach became ill, the team began to flounder; there was no organization, no rigor, and the practices tuned into just a bunch of friends kicking the ball around for fun. The team captain stepped up and organized the practices and basically took the coach’s place until a replacement coach could be found. He described his challenges in getting his friends and older team members to listen to him and how he overcame their resistance to a new leader and leadership style.
The second is similar to the soccer player but with deeper consequences. This person told the interviewer how her mother was a single parent of three children; she was the oldest. Her mother worked full-time leaving many of the household duties to her including taking care of her brother and sister. This candidate made sure that her siblings got home safely after school and completed their homework; she cleaned the house and got dinner started for her mother. She was effectively a surrogate parent for a good part of every day. Is this leadership? I think so. Is there any more responsibility than the daily welfare of your younger brother and sister?
My point is not only to frame examples for you but to show you that leadership is more than just being a team captain or a club president. You have to find your own example and be prepared to articulate it to the interviewer. The time to think of that example is not when the interviewer asks you, “Give me an example of a situation where you were a leader?” or “Please describe your leadership style.” The time to think about those questions is now.
I hope you found this section useful; please look for the next post where I tie
Academics, Athletics, Community Service, and Leadership together.

So what exactly do you need to do? The specific volunteer activity that you choose is not really important to the academy admissions office or the congressional selection committee. The fact that your chosen activity is done consistently over time and that you make a meaningful contribution is critical. Gaining leadership experience through volunteering is an added benefit. Let’s look at some hypothetical examples of community service. Candidate A participates in an annual walk for a charity, possibly participating four times during his/her high school career. Candidate B spends every Saturday morning at the senior center helping serve breakfast and cleaning up. Which candidate made a bigger impact? Another hypothetical example of comparison. Candidate X organized a backpack drive for a poor inner-city school as a senior project, this project was it was a one time event during their senior year in high school. Candidate Y came up with an idea to gather winter coats for the homeless. Y organized the project, encouraged classmates to get involved, found a local church to store coats, and worked with the local police to help distribute the coats to the needy. Candidate Y started the project as a freshman, continued organizing the project through senior year, and passed the project on to younger volunteers after he/she graduated. Both of these students did community service, both contributed, but only one candidate took it to the next level and displayed leadership.
Please don’t misinterpret that one project is a more worthy cause than another. These examples are simply used to illustrate that you must do something, you must contribute, and you must be able to demonstrate on an application and in a personal interview what you have accomplished. So, what do you do? Find something meaningful to you, a cause that you feel strongly about and one that you wish to devote a portion of your time to help. Hopefully, you can find an organization that matches your passion and you can contribute your time and efforts on a regular basis. Ideally, you start early and over time you take a leadership position on some aspect of the cause that you have chosen to help. What if there is no existing organization for your passion? You can choose another passion or take a leadership role and form an organization with your friends, family, classmates and other members of the community interested in your cause.
Before I end this section, I want to talk a little about Boy Scout Eagle projects and Girl Scouts Gold Star projects. Being a scout is a plus for academy selection; it shows leadership, teamwork, and activity outside of school and sports. Overall, scout participation is an excellent addition for a service academy candidate. In my opinion, a scout project is not truly community service. If you’re a scout you are required to complete a project to receive your Eagle or Gold Star. I view this as something more for you than for the community. I understand that the community greatly benefits from a scout project, but it is often a one-time event that is never repeated. A quarterly project such as a food drive for a year or two is more impactful than most one-time projects. This is not meant to diminish scout projects! A scout project is an excellent display of leadership, organization, and problem solving and I am very supportive of scouting. My only suggestion is to try to include additional community service opportunities during your high school years.
Many candidates ask, does it matter if I’m not the best athlete on my team(s)? In my opinion, no it isn’t. It’s important to participate and important to compete. When I see a candidate that isn’t the best but he/she plays more than one season and puts the work in to contribute to the team and be physically fit, that goes a long way. It is also impressive to read a coach’s recommendation letter that says something like this, “Ms/Mr. Doe has played XXX sport for all three (3) years, he/she has been a great contributor, a leader and can always be depended upon.” When I read that, I know that this person wasn’t the top athlete but he/she was probably the one that made every practice, was a fierce competitor, and supported his/her teammates.
The other question that I frequently hear is,” Is it important to play three seasons of sports?” In my opinion, it is, except if you’re an elite athlete. Elite athletes concentrate on one sport and train during the off season. It is understood that many coaches frown upon playing other sports because of the risk of injury. Playing more than one season shows that you are committed to physical fitness and understand team dynamics and leadership. Please don’t think that those that play only one season have a lesser chance of acceptance; they don’t, but they use the off season(s) to do other extra-curricular activities. Successful candidates that play only one or two seasons spent time in the off season pursuing other activities such as community service, the arts, other possibly higher academic interests, or a host of other activities to make them a more valuable candidate.


Math. Note that Naval Academy is at the top of the stack while the Merchant Marine Academy is at the bottom. No matter which academy or academies you are competing for, the SAT requirements are demanding. The positive thing about the SAT exam is that you can take it as many times as possible and all the academies will “super score” your results (take the highest scores in each category).
Have you taken the PSAT, ACT and/or the SAT and scored well on a national level? These are all important questions to consider. The earlier in high school that you think about a service academy, the more time you’ll have to work on these items and improve. We’ll spend a lot of time on academics in future posts.
